The first fifteen minutes after an accident determine everything. Not the next fifteen hours, not the next day—the immediate aftermath. What you do right then shapes whether your case will be worth $50,000 or $500,000, whether the insurance company settles fairly or tries to deny your claim, whether you have leverage or you’re scrambling to recover.
I’ve handled hundreds of accident cases. The outcomes divide sharply between two groups: people who did the right things in those crucial first minutes, and people who didn’t. The difference isn’t luck. It’s about evidence—what you gathered, what you documented, what you preserved.
Let me walk you through exactly what to do. Not what lawyers say you should do in theory. What actually works in practice.
Right Now: Stop and Get Safe
First thing—stop. California Vehicle Code § 20001 requires it. That’s not optional. That’s the law. If anyone’s injured, if there’s any property damage, you stop. Period.
But here’s what I tell clients: the law isn’t your biggest problem if you don’t stop. The real problem is that you’ve just destroyed your own case. An insurance company will tear apart every claim you make. You left the scene—you’re guilty of something, and now everything you say is suspect.
So stop.
Then assess: Are you hurt? Are your passengers hurt? Is it safe to stay where you are?
If your vehicle is blocking traffic and it’s safe to move it—meaning your engine runs and you’re not trapped by oncoming traffic—move it to the shoulder or a parking lot nearby. Vehicle Code § 20002 actually requires this. Moving your car doesn’t affect fault. It just gets it out of the roadway. Do it if you can.
If you can’t move it, turn on your hazard lights. Get yourself out of traffic. Stand on the curb or behind the guard rail. Do not stand between vehicles. I’ve represented clients hurt in secondary crashes because they were standing in the street after their first accident.
The 911 Call
Call 911 if:
- Anyone’s hurt (even “maybe”)
- There’s significant damage
- Traffic’s blocked
- You suspect the other driver was impaired
- The other driver is aggressive
Be honest. Tell them what happened. Give them your location clearly. Tell them if people are injured. That’s it. Don’t speculate, don’t guess, don’t try to explain fault. Let them ask questions.
Why does this matter? Because that call creates an official record. The police report that comes from that call is worth more to your case than almost anything else you’ll do.
Check on People
After you’ve made sure you’re safe, check if anyone else is hurt. Ask them directly. If someone’s bleeding or says they’re in pain, the ambulance is already coming (because you called 911, right?).
Here’s something people don’t understand: people don’t always feel injured right after an accident. Your body dumps adrenaline. You could have a fractured rib and not know it for three days. You could have a concussion and think you’re fine. Adrenaline is powerful.
So even if someone says “I’m okay,” that doesn’t mean anything. They’re probably still amped up. They might be injured and not even realize it yet.
Don’t move anyone who’s seriously hurt unless there’s immediate danger (fire, oncoming traffic). Movement can make spinal injuries worse.
Get Information from the Other Driver
I’m going to be blunt: the other driver will lie to you. Not always intentionally. But they’ll downplay their fault, question your version of events, try to establish that you caused the accident.
So don’t engage in liability discussion. Don’t apologize. Don’t say “I’m sorry.” Even an apology can be used against you later as an admission of fault.
Instead, exchange these five things:
- Name and phone number
- Driver’s license number (get the state too)
- Insurance company name and policy number
- Vehicle make, model, year, color, license plate
- Home address (to confirm later)
Take a photo of their license. Photograph their license plate. Get their insurance card and photograph it. Don’t rely on memory.
Don’t discuss what happened. Don’t say “You hit me.” Don’t say “I didn’t see you.” Don’t say anything about how the accident occurred. Just exchange information.
Document the Scene
Your phone is your most valuable tool right now.
Take photos of:
- The vehicles: All four sides of each vehicle. Close-ups of the damage. Deployed airbags. Broken lights. Paint transfer (this shows impact direction).
- The intersection/location: Traffic signals and what they show (if possible). Stop signs. Road markings. Lane lines. Skid marks (these show braking, speed, who was where).
- Conditions: Is the road wet? Is there gravel? Potholes? Is visibility clear or are there obstructions? Time of day (affects lighting). Weather.
- Your injuries: If you have visible injuries, photograph them now. Photos taken the same day the accident happened are valuable.
Take a video. Walk around the accident scene narrating what you see. “This is the intersection of Main and 5th. The traffic signal was facing me—I had a green light. The other vehicle was traveling northbound. Here’s the damage to my vehicle on the driver’s side.”
The video doesn’t have to be professional. In fact, it shouldn’t be. It should be you narrating what you observe. That’s infinitely more valuable than a polished video.
Find Witnesses
Look around. Who saw this?
Other drivers stopped? Get their information. Pedestrians nearby? Get their information. Someone in the store across the street? Get their information.
Write down or record their names and phone numbers. Ask them: “What did you see?” Don’t guide them. Don’t tell them what happened and ask if they agree. Just ask what they saw.
Get them to tell you what they observed. You want independent accounts, not people agreeing with your version because you led them.
One credible witness who has no stake in the outcome is worth more to your case than your own testimony. Adjusters and juries believe independent witnesses.
Talk to Police
When police arrive, provide your license, registration, and insurance card. Tell them what happened. The truth. Not a self-serving story. Just factual: “I was traveling south on Main Street. The light was green. The other vehicle turned left in front of me from the opposing lane. I couldn’t stop in time.”
Don’t speculate. Don’t guess. Don’t say things like “He must have been texting” unless you actually saw it. Stick to what you know.
Mention if the other driver seemed impaired. If they hit you and then drove away (and you chased them down), tell police. If they were aggressive or hostile, mention it.
Get the officer’s name and badge number. Get the report number. Ask when you can get a copy of the police report. Usually 5-10 business days.
After You Leave the Scene
Seek Medical Care
This is critical. I’m not saying get medical care because you might be injured (though you might be). I’m saying do it because it matters legally.
If you wait a week to seek care, the insurance company’s argument writes itself: “She felt fine enough to work for a week. She felt fine enough to go to social events. But now she claims she’s injured? This is convenient.”
Gaps between the accident and treatment hurt you. Insurance companies exploit those gaps ruthlessly.
Go to urgent care. Go to your doctor. Go to the ER if anything seems serious. Get evaluated the same day or the next day. Even if you feel fine. Get documentation from the medical provider that you were in an accident and you’re being evaluated for injuries.
This creates a paper trail. This shows you took your injuries seriously. This gives your case weight.
Notify Your Insurance Company
Within 24-48 hours, call your insurance company. Don’t email. Call. Tell them you were in an accident. Give them the date, time, location, and other driver’s information.
Don’t get into detail about your injuries. Don’t speculate. Don’t accept any settlement offers. Just report the accident.
They’ll ask if you want a claim adjuster to contact you. Yes. You want them engaged, not dragging their feet.
Do NOT Talk to the Other Driver’s Insurance Company
The other driver’s insurance will call you. They’ll be nice. They’ll say they just want to understand what happened. They’ll ask for a recorded statement.
Say no. You don’t have to talk to them. You’re not required to. What you tell them becomes a permanent record that will be used against you if this case gets complex.
If they press, say: “I appreciate you calling. I’m still receiving medical treatment and I’m not ready to give a statement. Please contact my attorney.”
(If you don’t have an attorney yet, just say you’re not comfortable giving a statement right now.)
Gather and Preserve Evidence
Get the police report. Get your medical records. Get your medical bills. Take photos of your injuries as they heal (the progression matters—shows the injury was serious). Keep receipts for everything related to the accident: rental cars, mileage, medications.
Don’t have your vehicle repaired yet. Don’t touch it. An insurance company’s appraiser needs to see the damage. They need to assess it. Photos aren’t enough—they need to see the actual vehicle. Then you can get it fixed.
Common Mistakes I See
Don’t post about the accident on social media. Don’t post photos. Don’t complain about the other driver. Don’t discuss your injuries. Insurance companies monitor social media aggressively. Innocent-looking posts become exhibits in your case.
Don’t skip medical appointments. Follow your doctor’s recommendations without exception. Missing appointments signals to the insurance company that your injuries aren’t serious. Insurance companies use this against you constantly.
Don’t accept quick settlement offers. The insurance company’s first offer is usually 30-50% below what the case is worth. They know you don’t understand your injuries yet. They know you’re desperate for money. Don’t take it. You can’t go back later and say “Actually, my injuries were worse. Give me more money.” Once you sign a release, you’re done.
Don’t wait too long to consult an attorney. California gives you two years to file a lawsuit, but evidence disappears. Memories fade. Witnesses move away. If your claim involves a government entity, you have six months to file an administrative claim—miss that and your case is gone entirely. Consult an attorney within weeks, not months.
When to Call a Lawyer
Call a lawyer if:
- You’re injured (even minor injuries)
- The insurance company seems hostile
- The other driver’s insurance won’t cooperate
- You’re unsure what your case is worth
- The other driver was uninsured
- You missed work
Most of us offer free consultations. You’re not hiring anyone by calling. You’re just talking to an experienced car accident attorney in Irvine who understands what your case is worth.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What’s the first thing I should actually do?
A: Make sure you’re not in immediate danger. If there’s traffic, get to safety. Call 911 if anyone’s hurt or if there’s significant damage. That’s it. Those two things. The rest comes after.
Q: Should I admit fault?
A: No. Even if you think it was your fault, don’t say it. You might not understand what the other driver did. You might not see what happened. Tell police facts: “I was turning left. A vehicle hit me.” Don’t say “I caused the accident.” Let investigators figure out fault.
Q: I feel fine. Do I really need to see a doctor?
A: Yes. Many injuries don’t show up immediately. Whiplash, concussions, internal injuries—these can take hours or days to appear. Get evaluated. Even if the doctor says you’re fine, you have documentation. Without it, the insurance company will argue you were never hurt.
Q: How long do I have to file a lawsuit?
A: Two years for personal injury, three years for property damage. But if a government entity is involved (city vehicle, road defect), you must file an administrative claim within six months. Missing that six-month deadline bars your entire claim.
Related Resources
- How to Find the Best Car Accident Attorney in Irvine (2026 Guide)
- The Role of Police Reports in Irvine Car Accident Cases
- Irvine Car Accident Claims: Dealing with Insurance Adjusters
- Understanding Comparative Negligence in Irvine Auto Accident Cases
- [Irvine’s Statute of Limitations for Auto Accident Claims]
—
About The Author
Cynthia A. Craig is a Founding Partner at Kubota & Craig in Irvine, California. Over her 20 years of trial work, she’s handled hundreds of auto accident cases—from straightforward rear-end collisions to complex multi-vehicle accidents. She’s seen what works in the first fifteen minutes after an accident and what gets clients undercompensated.
Cynthia is a past President of the Orange County Trial Lawyers Association and has been recognized by Best Lawyers in America and Super Lawyers for her work representing injury victims.
She works on contingency—meaning she only gets paid if you recover. So her incentive is straightforward: maximize what you receive.Licensed to practice in California | Member, Orange County Trial Lawyers Association
—Been in an accident? Contact Kubota & Craig at (949) 218-5676 for a free consultation. We’ll review what you did after the accident, identify what evidence is still recoverable, and give you a realistic picture of your case’s value. Most calls come too late (months after the accident), but if you call early, we can often preserve evidence and protect your rights.
Disclaimer: This article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with Kubota & Craig.
